Elisabeth Moss

Shirley Jackson

Odessa Young

Rose Nemser / Paula

Michael Stuhlbarg

Stanley Hyman

Logan Lerman

Fred Nemser

Victoria Pedretti

Katherine

Robert Wuhl

Randy Fisher

Paul O'Brien

Dean

Orlagh Cassidy

Caroline

Bisserat Tseggai

Peggy

Allen McCullough

Norman

Tony Manna

Drunken Fellow

Molly Fahey

Faculty Wife

E

Edward O'Blenis

Ralph Ellison

Ryan Spahn

Drunk Cad

E

Emily Decker

Prissy College Girl

A

Alex Sherman

Paula

A

Ava Langford

Rose's Friend

T

Thomas Racek

Party Guest

Lexa Hayes

Party Goer

Adelind Horan

Paula Double (uncredited)

Steve Vinovich

Henry (uncredited)